I’m listening to music on shuffle and “Lothlorien” is playing. Now I want to rewatch
The Fellowship of the Ring.
•
Hemlock & Silver by T. Kingfisher: Anja, an expert in poisons and antidotes, is asked by the king to determine if his ailing twelve-year old, Snow, is being poisoned.
This is a
very loose retelling of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (sans dwarfs). Mostly it feels like its own story but every so often Kingfisher weaves in another element of the original tale – and puts her own spin on it, of course. I really enjoyed that!
I also enjoyed the juxtaposition of Kingfisher’s practical, down-to-earth and unconventional protagonist with a royal household (even if said household is a distant, desert retreat rather than the main palace). There is also a similar contrast between the mystery about whether Snow
is being poisoned, which involves attention to mundane, unglamorous matters like Snow’s symptoms and habits, with the mystery of
why Snow is being poisoned, which much is more the plot from a fantasy.
Occasionally I skimmed over details about poisons that made me feel squeamish, but I didn’t mind the horror elements – perhaps because
Anja didn’t really mind them. Or at least her scientific fascination for what she discovers is stronger than any fear or disgust. Some of the time she’s also accompanied by a bodyguard, which might have also contributed to my perception that Anja was sufficiently invulnerable that I could relax enough to enjoy her adventures, even when those were rather creepy.
I liked how the romance is very much a subplot, too.
I’ve enjoyed all of Kingfisher’s fantasy but, upon reflection, I think this one qualifies as one of my favourites!
( ‘According to the herbwife, I would probably need to poison either dogs or prisoners, and I had moral objects on both counts. (Also, I was twelve and unlikely to be given access to the palace prisons for scientific purposes.)’ )
I have a train of thought that I started writing from last year. It bears no connection to
The Lord of the Rings or to
Hemlock & Silver, but I am going to endeavour to finish it and post it here anyway.
What does one do with beloved stories by people who have been revealed to be problematic?This is something I find myself pondering every so often. I’ll see a news article about a celebrity, reminding one of said celebrity’s problematic-ness. Or I’ll be wondering about something I have on my shelves (
Am I actually going to read that?). Or I will come across someone online explaining how
they think other people should be responding, and criticising and making assumptions about those who have, for example, certain books on their shelves.
I have concluded that I feel quite strongly that if one is making a decision personally – and not for a business/organisation/institution – then the answer is very personal. Case-by-case. Your mileage may vary.
( The trouble is when the personal ceases to be private and becomes performative, I guess. )